What are stanines?

Stanines are ranking scores from 1 to 9 derived from the Australian norm sample. Stanine scores group together percentile ranks to simplify the comparison of student achievement with the norm sample.

Stanines are not included in the ACER Data Explorer reports. The following table can be used to derive a stanine based on a student's percentile ranking. This table can be used for any assessments which provide Norm Data as it represents a normal distribution. 

DescriptionStanineCorresponding percentile ranksPercentage of students
Very high996th and above4
High890th-95th7
Above average777th-89th12
Average660th–76th17
Average540th–59th20
Average423rd–39th17
Below average311th–22nd12
Low24th–10th7
Very low13rd and below4

It's important to keep the following in mind when using stanines and percentiles

  • They only represent the ranking of achievement and cannot tell you anything specific about the skills demonstrated, nor be used to infer growth over time (a student could rank at stanine 5 every year, but they and their peers are likely still progressing in their learning).
  • Only the PAT scale scores can be used to measure actual achievement and to infer growth over time according to the PAT tests.
  • The national norm samples for most PAT assessments were collected towards the end of the school year (although not annually), so if your students completed their tests at the beginning of the year, it may be more meaningful/helpful to compare their results to those of the year level below in order to compare to students with a similar level of schooling.
  • Each test report generally offers the ability to compare to the year level towards the test is generally targeted, as well as the year level above and below. This means that if you administer 'off-level' tests to students according to their ability, it may not be possible to automatically generate stanines or percentiles based on comparisons to their year level.

 

Transcript

Stanines are rankings, from 1 to 9.  Stanines can be used to compare a test result from a student in a particular year level at your school with the typical performance of Australian students in that same year level. 

The norm distribution at each year level is divided into 9 groups based on the standard deviation of a normal distribution – the standard nine.  

Thee word ‘stanine’ comes from ‘standard nine’ and is where the normal distribution is divided into nine sections that have an equal width, except for the first and last which contain the tails of the distribution. This results in each section containing a different proportion of the population.

  • Stanine 1 contains the proportion of students with the lowest test scores, up to the 4th percentile.
  • Stanine 2 contains the next 7% of test results, up to the 11th percentile. 
  • Stanine 3 contains the next 12% of test results, up to the 23rd percentile.
  • Stanine 4 contains the next 17% of test results, up to the 40th percentile.
  • Stanine 5, in the middle of the distribution, contains the next 20% of test results, up to the 60th percentile.
  • Stanine 6 contains the next 17% of test results, up to the 77th percentile. 
  • Stanine 7 contains the next 12% of test results, up to the 89th percentile. 
  • Stanine 8 contains the next 7% of test results, up to the 96th percentile.
  • And Stanine 9 contains the top 4% of test results.

Stanines provide rankings but do not provide a reliable or useful measure of students’ learning growth.

Consider a situation where a student completed the Year 2 assessment last year, achieved a scale score of 122, a percentile of 90 and was placed in stanine. This year, the student in Year 3 completed an assessment, achieved a scale score of 128.0, a percentile of 87 and was placed in stanine 7.  

Does this mean the student went backwards because a lower stanine was achieved in Year 3? The answer is ‘no’. If a student’s scale score has increased, then they have improved in their learning, regardless of their percentile or stanine rank which only compares them with the norm.

Consider a situation where Student A and Student B sit a PAT assessment in Year 5. The results place both students in stanine 4. The following year, the two students sit the Year 6 assessment and are both again placed in stanine 4.

The stanine values themselves only give us part of the story. We need to look at the students’ scale scores.

Both Student A and Student B have improved their scale scores from Year 5 to Year 6, but there has not been any change in their stanines. However, according to the scale scores, Student B has improved her scale score more than student A.

This example demonstrates that you cannot observe growth using stanine rankings.

To measure a student’s progress over time, we need to forget about stanines and look only at the student’s scale scores.

Was this article helpful?
0 out of 0 found this helpful

Articles in this section

ACER News
News and expert insights on educational research and developments around the world
Magazine
Promoting quality teaching and leading, assisting school improvement at a grassroots level
Podcast
Honest conversations with leading educational practitioners